Showing posts with label book. Show all posts
Showing posts with label book. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 12, 2010

Book Look: Chuck Palahniuk's "Tell-All"

According to Chuck Palahniuk's Tell-All, a tell-all biography is written by sycophants who go about "vacuuming up the thorny anecdotes they'd need to flesh out two hundred pages." At least those muckrakers had anecdotes: this awful novel only has a repetitiously self-skewering "bizarre form of name-dropping Tourette's syndrome." The plot's obvious after the first three chapters (or "scenes," since this novel is sloppily written--like a treatment--by a character with delusions of the screen), but to spare you even that Sisyphean torment, here's the plot: Hazie Coogan, an obsessed fan in a maid's costume, carefully cultivates the image of her dithering film-star boss, Katherine Kenton, and plots to have her killed at the height of her "third act" in order to save her from the public vultures that would otherwise tear her (reputation) apart. The ride involves poking fun at Broadway musicals and Lillian Hellman; at rich, younger paramours and their ulterior motives; snobbish celebrities and their empty speech.

That ride, however, is not a fun one. Tell-All is a lie that doesn't even come close to telling a truth: it's an braying, repetitious, inane satire--of itself as much as the sort of audience that might read it. It is a book that is lost in its own devices: Act I's over-explained puns (divorced "happily-never-afters," suicidal "marry-kiri," and adoption-crazed "offspring shopping," to name a few), Act II's book-selling luridness ("subsequent to strenuous oral contact with my romantic meat shaft...," "abandoning the sodden glory of her puckered shelter, I spewed my steaming tribute, gush upon jetting gush, the pearlescent globules of my adoration and profound admiration..."), and Act III's rushed and rote Hollywood ending (not the good kind). These devices pass for description, with a sense of time given to us by the song currently playing on all the radios, and characterization expressed in vagaries like these: "Mervyn LeRoy spread the rumor that I am the secret love child of Wally Beery and his frequent costar Marie Dressler." Actual descriptions--and flat-out exposition--repeat, endlessly, sometimes within the same paragraph. The few lines that actually work are swallowed up by all the yawning emptiness. ("The entire effect, insular and silent as sleeping tucked deep inside Mae West's vagina.")

Tell-All tells us nothing about celebrity culture, it simply reflects back at us--a hundred-fold--what we already wrongly assume. Even the worst book of this sort reveals something about human nature--the writer's, if not the subject's; by distancing himself behind fiction, Palahniuk denies us even that.

Thursday, May 06, 2010

Book Look: Yann Martel's "Beatrice and Virgil"

Beatrice and Virgil is Yann Martel channeling Paul Auster as he calmly relates the story of a one-hit author--a stand-in for himself--who is stuck trying to write about the Holocaust in "a new way" until he encounters a taxidermist who has written a very Beckett-like play. The rest of the short novel--which at times resembles Michael Chabon's circuitous The Final Solution--revolves around excerpts of that play, and the author's attempts to define it. The sections on taxidermy-as-history are richly written, and the play itself--which follows Beatrice, a stubborn donkey, and Virgil, a howler monkey--is an excellent means of abstracting-to-the-point-of-clarity the enormous struggle to talk about something that cannot be talked about. Martel is aware that Beatrice and Virgil's clever, minimalist devices for naming the Horrors is not enough, lacking plot and action, but he does himself a disservice by succumbing to the most lackluster resolution possible, one that distracts from the otherwise elegiac emptinesses of the novel. However, he redeems himself with the tragic, conclusive short story, "Games for Gustav," and with his "sewing kit," a list of coping mechanisms that are far more than the sum of the whole.

See also: Brian K. Vaughn's Pride of Baghdad. 

Wednesday, June 03, 2009

Chuck Palahniuk, "Pygmy"

Chuck Palahniuk is an expert machinist, always coming up with creative new frames on which to mass-produce his same-old same-old anarchistic depravity. The problem is, after the first few rhythmic chapters of any Palahniuk novel, the formula quickly oxidizes, turning brittle and emotionlessly redundant. He's a cold, harsh writer, which is what draws masochistic and sadistic readers to worship at his cult. Perhaps it's just because, having skipped Rant and Snuff, I've recharged my capacity for Palahniantics, but Pygmy, his latest, manages to wiggle enough amid its precisely plotted and patterned sections to at least entertain.

The secret of Pygmy is that its untitled character, who refers to himself as "operative me," isn't entirely indoctrinated. Sure, he's come to the United States (along with many other agents from his totalitarian state) so that he can destroy it, using his foreign exchange cover to initiate "Operation Havoc." True, every chapter of the novel (a "dispatch") is meticulously reported in his broken, prepositionless English, complete with a repeating quote (one per dispatch) from his idols: Hitler, Stalin, Mao, and company. And yes, Palahniuk goes so overboard in burying his voice in bad grammar that he grinds every unique observation of Pygmy's down into a redundant, miserable powder: by the tenth time a door "heals" itself, or his "weapon" becomes "turgid" in his pants, it's just irritating. (Also, Palahniuk's voice *IS* still ominpresent via Pygmy's host family.) Palahniuk doesn't go as far as Burgess's Clockwork Orange, nor does his character's broken communication reveal as much as Haddon's The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-time.

What saves the narrative is the almost imperceptible frisson of Pygmy's not utter hatred of America, which allows him to make some poignant critiques of our culture. For instance, his recollections (from age 4 and up) are of training in moves like the "Striking Cobra Quick Kill," so when enrolled in an American school, a spelling bee is described as "Participate combat among student public education institution [redacted]. Forced battle to list English alphabet letters which compromise typical vocabulary word." The foreign-exchange students are so dedicated that the match continues for hours, making not only the American students restless--but the teachers, as well: "For official record, no impossible shouting death threat originated from renowned instructor."

As the novel progresses, Pygmy becomes more human and America grows less so, for it is shown to care so little for the things that actually matter. Pygmy's "host pig dog brother" sees love as pawing at "fun bags," but it is Pygmy who actually begins to fall for his "host sister, stealth cat." When one of Pygmy's classmates goes Columbine, he's the one who saves the helpless students (though he plans to use a neurotoxin on them later). Whereas the American girls flirt as casually as they abort, his fellow agent, Magda, is the one who comes to treasure motherhood. Coupled with his "host chicken" mother's Tupperware parties for sex toys and the amount of roofies fed to his "vast cow" father (by his own family!), it's hard to condemn Pygmy's choices. Palahniuk swings hard at religion, too, noting the similarities between Wal-Mart ("retail product distribution center") and church ("religion propaganda distribution outlet"); in this world, both even have the same elderly greeter, Mrs. Lilly, "esteemed madam soon rotting corpse."

It's no shock that Palahniuk's epigraph is Hitler's statement, "He alone, who owns the youth, gains the future." The shock is in realizing that it's not just Pygmy who has been indoctrinated, but rather all youths, who are constantly assailed by big business, big churches, "frenzied journalist attracted stench of human tragedy," and the social laws of school. Palahniuk seems to care a lot more for making cruder points, and cracking sicker jokes, but then again, he just understands his audience. And if there's the chance that some of them will shake off their wool and realize that, then Pygmy's worth reading.

Tuesday, March 17, 2009

Aravind Adiga, "The White Tiger"

Having never been to India, it's hard to say what the country is actually like, but it's fair to say that Aravind Adiga's debut novel, The White Tiger, has been such a success in America because it's what one imagines we would say the country is like. The rags-to-riches narrative quickly familiarizes capitalists with the story, but it also diminishes the exoticism (how similar all suffering is). The same is true of the voice of Adiga's narrator--while his tale is unique, his glib comic voice, all too familiar (even as a protective mechanism) can at times be deadening. (It's also pretty clearly Adiga writing; for a more impressive act of ventriloquism, see David Eggers's What Is the What.)

Despite these similarities, The White Tiger is a decent read. Like its protagonist, Balram Halwai, who works as a driver, the novel moves quickly, as safely as possible, and successfully transports you from beginning to end--it even occasionally "cracks the egg" of this vehicle to expose the reader to a few eclectic sights and sounds. For the casual reader seeking a "culturally significant" beach read, The White Tiger will serve them well--after all, Halwai introduces himself as a murderer who has become a successful businessman, an enticing (although unsuspenseful hook) that makes us plow on.

Furthermore, because the story is being "told" (relayed in an unsent letter to the premier of "the Freedom-loving Nation of China"), the pacing is neatly separated into sarcastic revelations about the "real" India ("One fact about India is that you can take almost anything you hear about the country from the prime minister and turn it upside down and then you will have the truth about that thing") and his own philosophical musings ("The Indian entrepeneur has to be straight and crooked, mocking and believing, sly and sincere, at the same time"). If there's a problem with any of this, it's that we have to take his smirky word for it; nothing grounds him to real emotion. When he chooses to actually describe his circumstances, it's then that he gets poetically creative--his grandmother, Kusum, is described as having "this habit of rubbing her forearms hard when she felt happy, as if it were a piece of ginger she was grating to release grins from." Sly and sincere at the same time, indeed--and has this entrepenurial author not succeeded in sending The White Tiger to the top of the charts?

Again, all this pandering is not a bad thing, and as a writing style, it does accurately depict the sort of false face that a member of the serving caste has to wear. The problem is that the mask rarely drops: Balram's amoral, and if he regrets condemning his family to death (for his crime), he doesn't show it. In fact, he relates his tale with such polish, such distance, that it hardly seems to have happened to him: why, in other words, should we listen?

Monday, February 02, 2009

Salman Rushdie, "The Enchantress of Florence"

Salman Rushdie's latest novel opens with a foreign stranger--appropriately modeled after the classic tricksters of fables and fantasies--approaching a golden lake that "looked like a sea of molten gold." Wealthy as the Mughal capital, Fatehpur Sikri, is, this is of course an illusion, the sun making the water appear otherworldly. The Enchantress of Florence has a similar effect: written in the embellished prose of a many-sleeved storyteller, it stretches a wanderer's journey into a golden epic. However, although there is an underlying "reality" of the novel, which walks between Arabian Nights-like fantasy and a grittier Florentine drama (the cadences sound Umberto Eco-ish there), let the strength of water itself not be forgotten. Much as Rushdie rambles, he also flows; for all that he gushes, he also channels.

If there are complaints with Rushdie's novel it is that, unlike his most remembered work (Midnight's Children and The Satanic Verses, or even The Ground Beneath Her Feet), this is magical realism without the realism. This is not to dismiss the five-page bibliography, but the exotic romances here--of blind elephant judges, voluminous prostitutes, poisons and princesses--keep the novel untethered. (Not to the degree of Moorcockian pulp that Michael Chabon dabbled in with the recent Gentlemen of the Road.) And yet, "the untruth of untrue stories could sometimes be of service in the real world." These "improvised versions of the endless stream of stories he had learned" will get both the golden-haired foreigner, Mogor dell'Amore, and his spiritual ancestor, Antonino Argalia out of many a predicament.

Enjoyable as the novel is to read, it's hard to identify a central theme--mainly because that theme deals with the physicalization of illusion. The stories within The Enchantress of Florence bring adventures to life for the reader, but they do so even more literally within the novel, for Emperor Akbar has willed his perfect queen, Jodha, into existence--through mass belief and rumor, treading the line between "delirium and sanity." When dell'Amore arrives with a secret for Akbar's ears only, he conjures up a new woman, Qara Kos, the "hidden" princess. Along these lines, there is much to be said for the secret ways in which women once had to wield their power in a world of men, though the novel is more engrossed in literary romance than physical romance.

Of course, The Enchantress of Florence doesn't always know what it is, and while that exotic patchwork of diaphanous stories works for the first half of the novel, some of the latter sections drag, as consequences often do. In some ways, however, it is necessary for Rushdie to have weak sections to his tale: if his illusion were perfect, it would be impossible to write of illusions; if love were truly indomitable, it would simply be enslavement.

Thursday, November 13, 2008

Paul Auster, "Man in the Dark"

"[W]hen sleep refuses to come . . . I lie in bed and tell myself stories. They might not add up to much, but as long as I'm inside them, they prevent me from thinking about the things I would prefer to forget." So speaks August Brill, who escapes his crippled life as a 74-year-old widower by fantasizing of Owen Brick, a party magician who finds himself tasked--in an alternate America that is at war with itself--with killing the man who has created this world: August Brill. Dip that pen a bit deeper, and you'll see that Man in the Dark is just an extension of Paul Auster (no metafictional stranger: he goes way back to City of Glass) telling himself stories about a violent war that he can control, so that he doesn't have to face the America that he can't.

To aid in this distraction, there are the usual Austerian topics: films are discussed (The Bicycle Thief, Grand Illusion, and The World of Apu), philosophers are mulled (Giordano Bruno), and literature is imagined (Rose Hawthorne's memoir). But in trodding over such familiar themes (Brick's adventures resemble a cheap noir) and focusing so much on the ideal of using "inanimate objects as a means of expressing human emotions," the book falls flat. Auster's prose has always been written in a procedural fashion, but here it seems professorial, too, and we are too often told things like "Brick is feeling so lonely, so discombobulated by the events of the past twenty hours, he wishes she would abandon her post behind the counter and accompany him to the hotel, but he knows she can't, and he's too timid to ask her to make an exception for him." Worse still, this short 180-page novel devotes half its space to this truly imaginary character--in fact, even pages to an alternative history that only stresses the distracted state both Auster and Brill find themselves in. Philip Roth wrote of another country in The Plot Against America to illustrate something frightening about the world today; Auster writes of another world because he's bored of this one. Poor him. Poor us.

Thing is, the rest of the novel isn't bad. Brill doesn't just dream of Brick's dead-end life, he remembers--with lived-in details that specify right down to the special deals on dinner rolls--people from his family. His sister, Betty, leads him to think about her marriage to Gilbert Ross, and consequently to describe Gil's life--from the Newark riots in the 60s to his law practice in California and the "more than twenty pills a day to keep himself alive." In eight pages, Auster fleshes out two full lives and uses them to reflect upon his protagonist's own situation, so is it any wonder that the sections with Brick seem so irritatingly leaden?

Ultimately, Man in the Dark turns into the sort of book Gilead might've been if it were a dialogue, with Brill talking to his granddaughter, Katya, about how he'd married, divorced, and then reunited with her mother. It's a happy story, another distraction in the dark, meant to turn Katya's grief away from the love of her life's death in Iraq. All of us are in the dark, goes the logic, and we must all of us turn to stories to save us. So far as one's reading a book goes, however, why would anyone want to stay in the dark?

Tuesday, October 28, 2008

David Foster Wallace, "McCain's Promise"

It seems a little inane to review McCain's Promise, a $9.99 republication of an essay ("Up, Simba") that already appears in David Foster Wallace's Consider the Lobster. Then again, it's a little crazy to be living in a world without DFW, and one in which John McCain, the subject of this 2000 essay (originally "reported" for Rolling Stone) is ungallantly repeating the mistakes of his primary campaign against Bush (a k a "The Shrub"). But and so then, because it would be crazy to imagine intelligent readers out there somehow missing this redundantly published yet wholly original essay, an ode to DFW, in review form:

First off, the genius of DFW, who--in footnotes, blocks of run-on text, or parentheical asides--always found a deeper connection to his material. In his fiction, this sometimes led to a solipsistic recursion, logical digressions and nested loops of introspection. But in his nonfiction, a new form of journalism was born, a synechdocal-gonzo hybrid that associated everything to everything. (Charlie Kaufman should be adapting Infinite Jest.) McCain's Promise proves to be no exception, "...not so much the campaign of one impressive guy, but rather what McCain's candidacy and the brief weird excitement is generated might reveal about how millennial politics and all its packaging and marketing and strategy and media and spin and general sepsis actually makes US voters feel, inside, and whether anyone running for anything can even be 'real' anymore."

So run the next 124 pages, a jampacked collection of observations not really about McCain, but about how McCain affected the political landscape, and about how badly we needed to feel something other than "the enormous shuddering yawn that the political process tends to evoke in us now in this post-Watergate-post-Iran-Contra-post-Whitewater-post-Lewinsky era, an era in which politicians' statements of principle or vision are understood as self-serving ad copy and judged not for their truth or ability to inspire but for their tactical shrewdness, their marketability." It's hard not to quote; as hard as it is to not absorb the richness of complex sentences like these, which nonetheless unfold like origami (hard to put together, easy to take apart).

It's all too easy to get lost in the abbreviation heavy language--not purple prose, but rainbow prose, effective prose, necessary prose--until you realize that despite the inclusion of words like "styptic," it's easy to stay afloat. Why? Because this essay is timeless, or at least prescient enough to describe America c. 2008: these observations transcend candidates and campaigns, and get to the root of what's wrong with politics: "It's easy to tell the truth when there's nothing to lose." How nice for DFW, then, who makes a point of reminding us that he's not a political journalist, and who punctuates this point by deriding the "12 Monkeys" (big political reporters for the MSM, distinguishable by their lack of distinguishability) and spending most of his time with the camera crew, with people like Jim C. who, because he's holding a boom mic just out of frame, is probably paying more attention than most people. Including this analysis of negativity:

Well no shit Sherlock H., the ABC techs in essence respond, good old Frank C. then explaining more patiently that, yes, if there's a low voter turnout [because the ugliness of the race has gotten voters so "bored and cynical and disgusted with the whole thing that they don't even bother to vote"], then the majority of the people who get off their ass and do vote will be the Diehard Republicans, meaning the Christian Right and the party faithful, and these are the groups that vote as they're told, the ones controlled by the GOP Establishment . . . [L]ow turnouts favor incumbents for the same reason soft money does.
As it turns out, DFW spends a great deal of time speaking in the vox populi, and it's this common tone that justifies all of his perfectly human and ultimately comic digressions ("Is it any wonder that over half of all US suicides take place in chain hotels?... Is it any coincidence that McCain's POW prison was known as the Hanoi Hilton?"), nay, which demands such momentum-stifling reports on the meaningless banality behind a campaign: "Editorial Meeting w/Detroit News. Press Conference at Weird Meth Lab-Looking Internet Company in Flint. Red-Eye to North Savannah on Chartered 707 with Faint PanAm Still Stenciled on Tail. Spartanburg SC Town Hall Meeting. Charleston Closed-Circuit TV Reception for McCain Supporters in Three States...Six Hours Flying for Two-Hour Fund-Raiser with NYC Supporters. Congressman Lindsey Graham Hosts Weird BBQ for a Lot of Flinty-Eyed Men in Down Vests and Trucker's Hats in Seneca SC." Could any other writer capture such mundanity (which is really the ghost of humanity) in the political machine?

This isn't an essay about the 2008 campaign any more than it's about the 2000 campaign, or about John McCain. It--like most, if not all of DFW's work--isn't actually even about politics, even though its observations and eerie parallels are always accurate. It's about life, the pulse of which persists in even the most artificial moments, and the hope behind all that stylized writing that we will always seek out, discover, and eventually achieve change. Here's a promise: read this essay--in fact, the whole collection. You will enjoy it.

Tuesday, October 14, 2008

Steven Millhauser, "Dangerous Laughter"

Steven Millhauser's new collection is clearly inspired by Borges' Ficciones, with eight of the thirteen short stories bound into the category of either "impossible architectures" or "heretical histories." But he's come a long way since he started chronicling lives in 1972's Edwin Mullhouse: the comically existential interpretation of a mutually destructive Tom and Jerry cartoon ("Cat 'n' Mouse") comes across as a polished George Saunders; the solipsistic refusal to speak and newfound pleasure in language ("History of a Disturbance") could be an accomplished Paul Auster. Not to mention the fainter echoes of contemporary wordsmiths like Ben Marcus ("A Change in Fashion") or the genre-dabblings of Michael Chabon ("The Wizard of West Orange"), who has an equal appreciation for the decor of an era.

This collection catches Millhauser at his inventive best, which is good, for he still has difficultly grasping (like many of the authors above) on actual characters. That is, this is a man better suited to describe situations and machinery than the people thrust into or operating them. Sometimes this has a neat payoff--in the most affecting piece of the collection, "The Disappearance of Elizabeth Coleman," the careful analysis of a mystery is turned back on the narrator, remarking on the significance of insignificance--although sometimes, as in the too-long "The Room in The Attic," it only serves to keep us in the dark. Others, like "Dangerous Laughter," fall into a middle place, where the story remains endlessly fascinating (in this case, the depiction of "laugh parlors" and their natural development in the endless quest for something new) even as the characters remain disaffecting and disaffected.

That's why Millhauser is best sticking with his Borgian instincts, and delving deeper and deeper into our the ever-changing (inwardly spiraling) trends of our world, as in the all-encompassing world of "The Dome," the dissatisfaction associated with perfection in "In the Reign of Harad IV," and the Babel-like distance created--our fluctuations high and low--by "The Tower." There's a sheer genius in Millhauser's ability to invent something totally new--and then to follow it through to its logical end, and his writing style follows that same clockwork precision. The joy of reading Millhauser may largely be an intellectual one, but it is a pleasure all the same to spend such provocative moments in the company of chroniclers of the ever disappearing present ("Here at the Historical Society") or reading the magical-realism behind a new form of highly life-like paintings (the verisimlist movement) that were "A Precursor of the Cinema."

Monday, October 13, 2008

Clay McLeod Chapman, "miss corpus"

Every author, by definition, uses artifice to shape a story. What determines their skill is the level of truth beneath that technique. Clay McLeod Chapman makes one mistake in miss corpus, relying on a too-literal (and literary) metaphor, one that makes the novel his child and his Southern setting the mother (I-95's both the backbone and the umbilical cord). In truth, that's just a purr in the engine as it warms up, and the moment Chapman launches into the first of his two collision-bound protagonists, William Colby, you might as well chuck Chuck Palahniuk to the side, crown a new king beyond Stephen King. This is not detached horror, or genre fiction: this is violence used to communicate the bruised, fleshy side of love, and it is shockingly sincere.

To achieve this effect, Chapman alternates between past and present, so that we begin to fall in love with Will's wife, Shelly, just as we learn that she is dead. He litters the page with delicate images, a culmination of the oxymoronic ugly beauty that he has perfected in his plays. As Will bends over the corpse--"Her neck looked like it had attempted to turtle her head down inside her rib cage, her shoulders swallowing up most of her throat"--he recognizes the manubrium, and suddenly we're seeing Shelly as she "wrapped her lips over the thin rim of bone, sealing those two hollows together." A moment later, as he "straightened out each of her limbs, kneading the rigor mortis free from her joints," we catch a lighter moment, mid-massage, as the two plan their road-trip honeymoon to Florida. Stricken with grief in the present, Will attempts to cling to the past in a way that, as narrated, is only slightly improbable, bundling his wife into coolers, and the coolers into the backseat, driving down I-95.

This journey gives Chapman the opportunity to play with the monologues of other characters, the sort of people who are largely ignored in fiction. There's Wallace Reese, who describes what it's like to work in a toll booth (he brings an empty jug to work), and also Audrey Dow, who sadly recalls what sex is like in a meatlocker--not to mention Will's strange encounters with a boy with a corncob for an arm, the "preggers special" of an abortion doctor, and through it all, his sweet memories of life with Shelly. Cumulatively, it distorts the normal material of fiction, hewing to a familiar narrative, but skinning off the cliched descriptive fat and boiling it alive. We could all live for lines as gothically descriptive as the lonely son of a motel owner's "Counting sheep didn't help. I simply scraped them off my skull, one by one," or his eerie descriptions of a fire (which could've come straight from his play, Volume of Smoke): "With those kids still in their evening attire, looked to me like they were all dancing--the boys with their molten tuxedos, the girls in their scorched gowns. They partied until they dropped, one by one. Bet it was the best prom they'd ever had."

Every time things get too dark, Chapman switches gears, which allows him to continue down I-95, and to fittlingly describe the unsettling and often unwritten flipsides to every happy story. In the largest of these shifts, the narration switches to follow Phil. As the cops at last dredge his son's corpse out of a Florida swamp, he bundles the corpse into his car to reunite with his wife, up in South Carolina, the opposite direction of Will, but along the same road, which allows us to continue reading more or less in tandem. This device (Northbound/Southbound) is unnecessary, but it does get across the unversiality of grief.

Miss Corpus is a tragically sweet story that catches Chapman as he transitions from short story to novel form. If there are a few bumps in the telling, better to simply appreciate the courage it takes to drive an off-road tale like this. Better still to simply roll down one's blinders and enjoy the bold breeze of the ride.

Thursday, October 02, 2008

James Wood's "How Fiction Works"

Struggle, dear readers and writers, to outwit that inevitable aging that puts novelist life always on the brink of mere convention. So concludes James Wood, a very excellent critic, after 247 raptly meandering pages through the passionate history of the novel (as we know it). So sure is he that it's near impossible to quibble with his close-reads and profound analyses: if we disagree with his perspective, it is only because he has succeeded in waking up our own literary taste buds. For lack of a better word, or perhaps because it is the best word: bam!

Though he constantly contradicts himself--either directly (as he explains why round characters are critical, but why flat ones can also be necessary) or indirectly (he frequently makes Roland Barthes play devil's advocate)--Wood holds several things in high esteem. Profound noticers trump the lengthy abstractions of David Foster Wallace, who uses the "free-indirect style" (when a third-person voice is influenced by the character it is observing) to override character. He also swoons for Gaerard Manley Hopkins's "thisness," Christopher Isherwood's "recording camera" of a pen, and Flaubert's ability to notice and compress the time signatures of an entire town.

What is more important, however, is that Wood holds nothing in low esteem (or at least does not specify the genre works that he avoids): he believes a novel fails "not when the characters are not vivid or deep enough, but when the novel in question has failed to teach us how to adapt to its conventions, has failed to manage a specific hunger for its own characters, its own reality level." No surprise, then, that his strongest section is "Detail" ("While we should try to be the kind of writer on whom nothing is lost, we have no need to be the kind of writer on whom everything is found"), while his blandest section psychoanalyses: "Truth, Convention, Realism," begins by quoting Rick Moody and Patrick Giles at length, then dismisses them as "more or less nonsense." (How Fiction Works helps to draw attention to the preciseness of imprecise words, even those that fall into cliche--because doesn't even cliche tell us something?)

Then again, this is bound to happen when one sets out with the admirable, yet down-to-earth goal of asking a critic's questions and offering a writer's answers. Wood is bound to his source materials, for every time he gets hung up arguing the merits of verisimilitude and artifice, someone like Virginia Woolfe will ask "Why should a real chair be better than an imaginary elephant?" In fact, Wood is clearest when anchored to detail: his favorite metaphor is the one which "estranges and then instantly connects, and in doing the latter so well, hides the former. The result is a tiny shock of surprise, followed by a feeling of inevitability."

Would that I could give How Fiction Works as close a reading as Wood provides for his heroes, but if there's anything this book demonstrates, it's the lack of comparative experience I have to Mr. New Yorker. Allow George Eliot, then, to carry us out with a beautiful reason for fiction and my personally renewed mission: "Art is the nearest thing to life; it is a mode of amplifying experience and extending our contact with our fellow-men beyond the bounds of our personal lot." Onwards, then, and upwards.

Tuesday, August 26, 2008

Steven Hall's "The Raw Shark Texts"

Steven Hall's The Raw Shark Texts opens in the style of Philip K. Dick's Paycheck, with a near dead man trying to save his own life by following the directions of his former self, Eric Sanderson the First. Except that the thing chasing him, a Ludovician word shark (or rather, the idea of one), belongs more to the metafictional world of Haruki Murakami (yes, there's a cat in this novel), as does the underlying tale of a lost love. Any good story is built on solid foundations and good ideas, and Hall's borrowed liberally from the sturdiest of authors, culling bits of solipsism from Paul Auster and highbrow adventure from David Mitchell. There's plenty of pop culture, too, and the climax can only be described as Jaws meets Mark Z. Danielewski's House of Leaves. Above all, there are the staples of modern thrillers: a constant array of cryptographic puzzles and one long extended chase scene, which manages to avoid being repetitive on grounds of sheer inventiveness.

"Bang -- another hit directly behind and under me, much harder, like a slow-motion car crash and the back end of the sofa thrown up and coming toppling forward, sending me sprawling off into empty space and then the carpet and the floor came up at me and it -- broke. The idea of the floor, the carpet, the concept, feel, shape of the words in my head all broke apart on impact with a splash of sensations and textures and pattern memories and letters and phonetic sounds spraying out from my splashdown. I went under, deep, carried by the force of my fall and without the thought or image or any recollection of oxygen or breathing at all."
Admittedly, it gets harder for Hall to make potent observations about how minute and grain-like our petty signs and signifiers are, in light of it all. The first half of the book seems crammed full of insight ("Every single cell in the human body replaces itself over a period of seven years. That means there's not even the smallest part of you now that was part of you seven years ago"), whereas the second half is more like a Zen action novel, with our memoryless hero exploring the underbelly of un-space, pursuing leads with shadowy men like Nobody, and sucked into the schemes of people like Scout and Trey Fidorious, who are trying hard to defeat a collective consciousness named Mycroft Ward. And yet, it all glides smoothly over this ocean of words, a world which thinks of memes as single-celled organisms of thought, ones which can gradually accumulate into larger creatures, like the luxophage, a parasitic idea lamprey that eats away at one's ability to think quickly or logically.

The Raw Shark Texts is, essentially, a symbiont, a complex organism that is living on, beneficially, within the reader, sparking the mind with a new, albeit fantastical, way to view the world. Nibble by nibble, the breadcrumb memories of this story will reel you in, until you're caught, hook, line, and sinker, racing through the words to their most satisfying conclusion.